Quote:
|
Originally Posted by China Cat
In Christianity we have a conception of what the pre-christian Jewish experience was that heavily colors our understanding of what Jesus means as messiah and savior. We take as fact a Christianized version of what all that stuff in the Torah means based on a very superficial understanding of the material. But I've been talking to Jews and they don't see it the way we do. So, digging down into the layers I'm first confronted with the disparity between Jewish and Christian thought about what the geniune context of the Torah, and the balance of the OT is.
Now I'm intrigued and I wonder what the real history of Judaism is outside of the foundational mythology. I want to know how and why the foundational myths were created. See, that's part of historical context that explains the Bible authors' original intent. So I look for unbiased sources, and I find that the archaeological record doesn't support the historicity of the foundational myths. O.K., so they're myths, and that makes them very powerful in their proper sphere, but it also completely undermines any possible literality in the Jesus story where elements of the Jewish myth are appropriated and used for color, nuance, ambience, or detail.
|
China Cat,
This is basically a path I took as I stepped back to evaluate just what is it I believe. For I realized a need to explore Christianity from a Jewish perspective rather than the sanitized Gentile version that is common across the major denominations. I, too, have faced seeming irreconsolable differences particularly in regards to Messianic prophesy (read Isaiah 7:14) and Messianic expectations. So I struggle to find harmony with the Jewish Moshiach, as defined in Judaism, and Jesus as the Christ. It certainly throws an unnerving wrench into the machine.
I haven't yet explored fully the archealogical aspects of the problem. Did you happen to catch the documentary "
Exodus Decoded"? If so, what did you think about it?