Search results

You don't have to be. You just need to make absolute statements of something you know about. Like you claimed about the Muwatta, and Bukhari, and Muslim, and your false claim about the 13th century you withdrew because later realised you claimed falsely, and then you changed it to the 12th...

That's absolutely true. It's a no true scotsman fallacy. Excellent. Very good. You should not. That's why you should study the subject. Good policy.

Very good question. My source of Pali as any Pali school that educate people is the Tipitaka and the tradition of the language taught in the script. It's great that you are asking for sources rather than making conjecture like you did and saying "Yes I am assuming" about a language that you...

Very good question. My source of Pali as any Pali school that educate people is the Tipitaka and the tradition of the language taught in the script. It's great that you are asking for sources rather than making conjecture like you did and saying "Yes I am assuming" about a language that you...

I exactly mean that English sentence. I don't know if I should say it in another language. I thought you said that you only know English. So what do you expect me to do? Say this in another language to an English speaker? You are not aware. You are not aware mate. You are not aware. You...

I think that when someone makes a comment about "what someone taught", the source of that persons teachings are important at least for authority or integrity. Otherwise, one could simply be misquoting a good person. That's the reason I always ask for sources. It's not that one is dishonest or...

Interesting. Where does he say the Buddha's teachings are encapsulated?

Actually, that has been a view of many theists throughout history. There have been many who believed that anyone who is tyrannical and murderous don't really believe in God or theism but are just pretending, and are atheists. It's not necessarily an individual view but a scholarly view of some.

Haha. You got it. ;)

Wahabi and Salafi? When you use these kind of terms it's so highly popularised but weirdly no one seems to understand any of this. Let me ask you a question. If you found a group of people who wanted to reform the whole of Islam and not adhere to traditions and traditional scholars? A group...

How many mosques have you visited and participated in these "conversations"?

I know that in some countries there are some fanatical muslims, but I am not going to generalise anything to anyone like that. The USA has 1% Muslims. ;) I don't know what's meant by radicalised though. People use terms arbitrarily and people have their own versions and perceptions.

They are serious. Another thread later. Lol. Of course. Do you think Salafi "scholars" embrace the entire history? Do you even know what Salafi is? Salafi's are a reformist group. I don't think you know the Salafi movement properly. Nevertheless, Don't keep such dogmatic blind faith on a group...

Ah. But Salafi and Deobandi are polar opposites in all kinds of matters. But that's no topic for now. Brother. Ahadith are not just "muslims differ" matter. When people differ, you have to look at why they differ. Im sorry but you are not available to think about it. You have your faith in a...

That's a generalisation and a deviation from what ever I said as if you didn't ask this question and clarified and again as if you don't understand what I have said. That's even against any kind of Islamic scholarship ever in the history of the universe. Your own "majority of scholars" that...

Or as Dantaswami one.

That means he is promoting his business. But I truly appreciate you giving his name in youtube, although I will never visit it since he was marketing it in the forum. Cheers.

Hmm. You are right. Not bad mate. Appreciated.

To me personally, these terms you are using are just bottomline in meanings. Apa meaning going against so apaddharma would mean going against the way or a bad or dirty way, and sukshma would mean to be precise or highly and precisely address something, and nishedha meaning prescribed if I may...

Very impressive brother. Most people around the world are not aware of Hindu philosophy. Don't get offended of me calling it "philosophy" and you could call it Dharma or what ever is the right terminology used by you. But for the rest of the world who are not Hindu in origin or in theological...