Namaste all,
thank you for the topic, brian.
unfortunately for us all... war is hell. this isn't some colorful metaphor to try to indicate the horrible conditions that one has to face.. it is, literally, hell.
beings in hell do all manner of things which, were they in other conditions, they would not engage in. it is difficult for those of us not in those situations to have a grasp of what they are going through.
that being said... i'm rather split on the whole thing.
there are aspects of this that are worse than other aspects so i think we need to be a bit specific.
murder (killing of any kind, really) is right out. sodomy is out, rape is out, physical torture is out as well. if these techniques are not allowed to be employeed (and they should never be, in my opinion) how does one get a hardened jihadist to divulge where the next terrorist action will be?
psychological techniques are used to break the prisoner at which point information can be extracted.
this has been a method employeed by militarys from time immemorial... remember how the Shou Emperor put the heads of the captured leaders on poles and marched into battle with them? ok.. well.. maybe you don't, but that's ok. the Mongols would raze the first city they fought in a new region to extert psychological pressue on the remaining citizens, military and nobility to surrender or face the same brutality.
have i already mentioned that war is hell?