What is Truth?!

Kindest Regards, Knowledge!

It is getting late and I have to work tomorrow. This will be my last post this evening.

I realize you are zealous for your faith, I applaud you for that. But be aware that zealousness can cloud your reasoning. Please go back and read my post about master (little "m") of my fate and captain of my soul. Being overzealous can take you far away from where Jesus intended you to be.

I will not argue with you about the derogatory term homie, I grew up on the streets of Los Angeles, I know very well where it came from and what it means, home boy. I am NOT your home boy, and I will not tolerate offensive language or incitement of ANY type from ANY one.

For now, you will have to settle for my response to this one thing:
we can love and tolerate anything, just as long as it doesnt go against God's will. He is the one we need worry about first and foremost!
I agree with you in principle, pertaining to things like murder, rape, pedophilia, etc. But when it comes to God's creation I must ask, how do you personally know the mind of God? I don't even pretend to. Some things I take on faith, I do not ask why. I do not ask why God created the billions of people the way He did, to believe in Him in the way He saw fit. I do not pretend to know what He has in mind for all of these people that love Him, and do what He has placed in their hearts to do. They are not going to hell, whether you believe that or not. I do not know God's mind, I just revel in the glory that is God's majesty, and take pride and pleasure in loving the things He has created. With all of its quirks and mysteries, this is still a beautiful world. And there are still a whole lot of beautiful people in it. Not all of them are Christian, not all of them are white, not all of them are conservatives, not all of them are smart, or pretty, or funny. But they are beautiful because they love God as they understand Him. I can live with that, and I sleep a whole lot better at night now that I don't think everybody should be just like me. ;)
 
Kindest Regards, Knowledge!

LOL. Are you the guy that banded me from posting before? If so, I'd like to ask. What did I do wrong? Certainly I did NOT force my thoughts on anyone, neither did I say that I was right and you guys were wrong. I just wrote what I believe, right?

I realize you are zealous for your faith, I applaud you for that. But be aware that zealousness can cloud your reasoning. Please go back and read my post about master (little "m") of my fate and captain of my soul. Being overzealous can take you far away from where Jesus intended you to be.

I agree with you about being overzealous. Please, do tell me when I begin to act as such!

I will not argue with you about the derogatory term homie, I grew up on the streets of Los Angeles, I know very well where it came from and what it means, home boy. I am NOT your home boy, and I will not tolerate offensive language or incitement of ANY type from ANY one.

Whoa! You said "I am not your home boy." Sounds kinda mean, dont ya think? Again guy, I ment no disrespect. But, to help you feel better, I'll be sure to watch for specific words that I may normally use. Im from NY, by the way. Up here, cats are so up tight. Well, most cats, at least.

I agree with you in principle, pertaining to things like murder, rape, pedophilia, etc. But when it comes to God's creation I must ask, how do you personally know the mind of God? I don't even pretend to.

Good question! God has given us a reverlation of who he is in his word, the Bible. It has stood the test of time, and proves to be the very word of God. This is how I know what God wants of his people. Its not like I make it up as I go along in life, that would be foolish!

Some things I take on faith, I do not ask why. I do not ask why God created the billions of people the way He did, to believe in Him in the way He saw fit. I do not pretend to know what He has in mind for all of these people that love Him, and do what He has placed in their hearts to do. They are not going to hell, whether you believe that or not. I do not know God's mind, I just revel in the glory that is God's majesty, and take pride and pleasure in loving the things He has created. With all of its quirks and mysteries, this is still a beautiful world. And there are still a whole lot of beautiful people in it. Not all of them are Christian, not all of them are white, not all of them are conservatives, not all of them are smart, or pretty, or funny. But they are beautiful because they love God as they understand Him. I can live with that, and I sleep a whole lot better at night now that I don't think everybody should be just like me.


Interesting thoughts. I once thought like that too. And, I imagine that many have before they found God. But, I'd just like to say this this - it pretty much facilities what you've aleady said. If you do not know God, why do you pretend to know what he wants us to do? Why would you go on in life thinking that you're right in what you believe? Will you never take God on his words? What I mean is this: The Bible claims to be the VERY WORD of God, and begs a person to test it to see if its true. It asks that you read, study, and believe its claims. And, when you do that, while asking God to reveal truth, the Bible says God will prove his truth to you. So, if you've never done this, why would you go on thinking that you know what God wants, when you're just a man? Will a finite man, without a reverlation from God, ever know what an infinite God wants of him?

I dont think so! But ofcourse, this is just my own thoughts and beliefs, based off a book that claims to be God's words. And, you know what? I could in fact be wrong!
 
Kindest Regards, Knowledge!
LOL. Are you the guy that banded me from posting before? If so, I'd like to ask. What did I do wrong?
It's taken you long enough. I have not hidden from you. If you had read what I wrote, then and now, you would know.

That said, as long as you play nice, you are welcome to continue playing. :D
 
No doubt, I intend to play nice. All I ask of you is that you dont judge me for speaking what I believe is truth. And, dont worry, Im not in the business of judging others when Im just as guilty as everyone else!
 
OK, last post, for sure this time.
Interesting thoughts. I once thought like that too. And, I imagine that many have before they found God.
No. I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong. Then I found God, then I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong because God is always right and never wrong. And then God slapped me upside the head and showed me just how wrong I can be!

But, I'd just like to say this this - it pretty much facilities what you've aleady said.
Yes, and your point is?

If you do not know God,
Now you are putting words in my mouth. Have you seen yet, how you misconstrue things people say? I have seen you misinterpret many times, not just me, but others too. If you are capable of misinterpreting me, don't you think that maybe, just maybe, you might misinterpret the Bible too? And as for believing you know the mind of God...be very careful, dear friend. If you have actually read the Bible, the same one you thump on, then you know intimately that that is blasphemous.

why do you pretend to know what he wants us to do?
I don't pretend. My lessons come from the same source you claim, the Bible.

Why would you go on in life thinking that you're right in what you believe?
For the same reason you do.

Will you never take God on his words?
Will you?

What I mean is this: The Bible claims to be the VERY WORD of God, and begs a person to test it to see if its true. It asks that you read, study, and believe its claims. And, when you do that, while asking God to reveal truth, the Bible says God will prove his truth to you.
Did it ever occur to you that you are preaching to the choir?

So, if you've never done this,
Apparently you do not think you are speaking with someone who knows just a little bit more than you...With all of the love and respect I can muster, son, you're still wet behind the ears. You're still drinking milk, and I've been chewing on meat for years. No disrespect, you're not even in the same ballpark. I'm doing my best to bring you up to speed, but you're fighting it the whole way. Give the controls over to God, stop trying to do it all yourself.

why would you go on thinking that you know what God wants, when you're just a man?
That is the question I asked of you. I know what God wants me to do, what He wants all of His children to do. But I do not pretend to know what goes on in His mind. For you to imply you do, when your little pea brain and my little pea brain together aren't big enough to hold a tiny fraction of His thought?

Will a finite man, without a reverlation from God, ever know what an infinite God wants of him?
A revelation from God? Are you saying you hear voices in your head? If not, and you mean the revelation of God's word, the Bible, it is still YOUR INTERPRETATION of what the word says. Have you considered that maybe, just maybe, YOUR INTERPRETATION may not be the correct one? I think of that, everyday. I hone my sword sparring with people like you for fun.

But ofcourse, this is just my own thoughts and beliefs, based off a book that claims to be God's words. And, you know what? I could in fact be wrong!
I see the words, but I don't think you mean them. You do not fully appreciate, down to your marrow, what your words mean. That much is evident all through your posts. Even if we accept the English Bible as infallible, it is still subject to our individual interpretation. Two examples (answer them both correctly and I'll get off your case): What does the word "divers", as found in the King James Bible, mean? Jacques Cousteau it ain't. Why are the words in italics?
 
OK, last post, for sure this time.

LOL! Either what I say is interesting, or you must be bored.

No. I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong. Then I found God, then I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong because God is always right and never wrong. And then God slapped me upside the head and showed me just how wrong I can be!

Very nicely said! I agree with what you said there. But, here's the difference with you and myself. I am not teaching something new, or telling people my own thoughts. Rather, Im telling what has already been said in the Bible by God. I guess you can say Im plagiarizing God's words. All that said, I guess this goes back to what I've said before - I believe the Bible is God's true words.

Yes, and your point is?

I dont know! What did I say before?

Now you are putting words in my mouth. Have you seen yet, how you misconstrue things people say? I have seen you misinterpret many times, not just me, but others too. If you are capable of misinterpreting me, don't you think that maybe, just maybe, you might misinterpret the Bible too? And as for believing you know the mind of God...be very careful, dear friend. If you have actually read the Bible, the same one you thump on, then you know intimately that that is blasphemous.

I think you're misunderstanding what I write? This is so much easier in person. Im almost tempted to send you a recording, that you may know exactly what Im saying. All that said, let me say this: I do not claim to know the mind of God, just what he has revealed to us in his word, nothing more!

I don't pretend. My lessons come from the same source you claim, the Bible.

I thought you might say that. I guess we should discuss the Bible. Obviously one of us is wrong, as truth cannot be relative - we both cant be right. Right?

Quote:
Will you never take God on his words?

Will you?

LOL! Im guessing your really sleepy here? Seriously though, I have taken God on his words, and have come to see the truth - Jesus the Christ is the ONLY way to God, because he has paid the price for our breaking God's Laws, and has freed us from the penility of the Law.

Quote:
What I mean is this: The Bible claims to be the VERY WORD of God, and begs a person to test it to see if its true. It asks that you read, study, and believe its claims. And, when you do that, while asking God to reveal truth, the Bible says God will prove his truth to you.

Did it ever occur to you that you are preaching to the choir?

Yes, most definitly! But, there are times when Im like, "Whoa..This guy went left on me...I thought he was agreeing, but I guess I was wrong?" Im sorry if Im wrong, but you continually give me the impression that you do not believe that Jesus is the ONLY way to God.

Apparently you do not think you are speaking with someone who knows just a little bit more than you...With all of the love and respect I can muster, son, you're still wet behind the ears. You're still drinking milk, and I've been chewing on meat for years. No disrespect, you're not even in the same ballpark. I'm doing my best to bring you up to speed, but you're fighting it the whole way. Give the controls over to God, stop trying to do it all yourself.

No offense taken! But, I have to laugh though. Not at you, I just thought what you said was very funny! Good one!! That out the way, lets discuss the core fundaments of the Bible. Again, I wish to show you where you've been in err for 25 years.

Quote:
why would you go on thinking that you know what God wants, when you're just a man?

That is the question I asked of you. I know what God wants me to do, what He wants all of His children to do. But I do not pretend to know what goes on in His mind. For you to imply you do, when your little pea brain and my little pea brain together aren't big enough to hold a tiny fraction of His thought?

I agree with you here - I dont know the mind of God. I just know what he wants me to do. Again, he revealed it in his word. He wants me to preach the truth to all that they will believe and come to the Savior, that they may be forgiven of their sins, and have eternal life.

Quote:
Will a finite man, without a reverlation from God, ever know what an infinite God wants of him?

A revelation from God? Are you saying you hear voices in your head? If not, and you mean the revelation of God's word, the Bible, it is still YOUR INTERPRETATION of what the word says. Have you considered that maybe, just maybe, YOUR INTERPRETATION may not be the correct one? I think of that, everyday. I hone my sword sparring with people like you for fun.

Yelling are we? I hope you're not getting fustrated with me. I ask that you have patience with me, as you know, I've only been walking with the Lord for 2 years now. That said, I've heard the "maybe you're interpreatation wrong" statement many times by people who dont know what the Bible says. I'll tell you what I've told them - "I do not interprete the Bible. Instead, I let the scritptures interprete themselves. And, with the help of the Holy Spirit, I know the truth that God wants me to know, because it lines up with his words in scripture. In 25 years of reading the Bible, have you actually found out what exactly the Bible reveals?

Quote:
But ofcourse, this is just my own thoughts and beliefs, based off a book that claims to be God's words. And, you know what? I could in fact be wrong!

I see the words, but I don't think you mean them. You do not fully appreciate, down to your marrow, what your words mean. That much is evident all through your posts. Even if we accept the English Bible as infallible, it is still subject to our individual interpretation. Two examples (answer them both correctly and I'll get off your case): What does the word "divers", as found in the King James Bible, mean? Jacques Cousteau it ain't. Why are the words in italics?

Of course I could be wrong. Just because I dont believe I am wrong, doesnt mean that I dont consider the possiblity of me being wrong. You know? That said, I have no idea what you're talking about with "divers" and "Jacques Cousteau." Whats your point? About the Bible being subject to indivisual interpretation though. Yes, I agree. And, I believe this is the mistake people make when reading the Bible. The Bible is not a book to be subjected to human reasoning, or interpration. Rather, it is the plain truth that God wants us to know. If we truely are born again, the Bible says, we will KNOW what God wants us to know. This is a supernatual occurence given to us by a supernatual God, when we become born again. If we're not born again, we'll vainly go about thinking we know what God says. PLEASE NOTE: Im NOT IN ANYWAY insinuating that you're not born agian. Im not in the business of judging someone's salvation. That said, I do believe you have somethings very twisted!

OK all that said, I have a request. Can you and I discuss the Bible? I want to see what your thoughts are on the core essientials, e.g., Jesus being the only way to God, the Godhead (Trinity), Salvation through grace, Heaven, hell, etc. If you want, we can start with discussing Jesus being the only way to God.

Thanks!
 
Conscience said:
OK, last post, for sure this time.

LOL! Either what I say is interesting, or you must be bored.

No. I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong. Then I found God, then I thought everybody should be like me, that I was always right and never wrong because God is always right and never wrong. And then God slapped me upside the head and showed me just how wrong I can be!

Very nicely said! I agree with what you said there. But, here's the difference with you and myself. I am not teaching something new, or telling people my own thoughts. Rather, Im telling what has already been said in the Bible by God. I guess you can say Im plagiarizing God's words. All that said, I guess this goes back to what I've said before - I believe the Bible is God's true words.

Yes, and your point is?

I dont know! What did I say before?

Now you are putting words in my mouth. Have you seen yet, how you misconstrue things people say? I have seen you misinterpret many times, not just me, but others too. If you are capable of misinterpreting me, don't you think that maybe, just maybe, you might misinterpret the Bible too? And as for believing you know the mind of God...be very careful, dear friend. If you have actually read the Bible, the same one you thump on, then you know intimately that that is blasphemous.

I think you're misunderstanding what I write? This is so much easier in person. Im almost tempted to send you a recording, that you may know exactly what Im saying. All that said, let me say this: I do not claim to know the mind of God, just what he has revealed to us in his word, nothing more!

I don't pretend. My lessons come from the same source you claim, the Bible.

I thought you might say that. I guess we should discuss the Bible. Obviously one of us is wrong, as truth cannot be relative - we both cant be right. Right?

Quote:
Will you never take God on his words?

Will you?

LOL! Im guessing your really sleepy here? Seriously though, I have taken God on his words, and have come to see the truth - Jesus the Christ is the ONLY way to God, because he has paid the price for our breaking God's Laws, and has freed us from the penility of the Law.

Quote:
What I mean is this: The Bible claims to be the VERY WORD of God, and begs a person to test it to see if its true. It asks that you read, study, and believe its claims. And, when you do that, while asking God to reveal truth, the Bible says God will prove his truth to you.

Did it ever occur to you that you are preaching to the choir?

Yes, most definitly! But, there are times when Im like, "Whoa..This guy went left on me...I thought he was agreeing, but I guess I was wrong?" Im sorry if Im wrong, but you continually give me the impression that you do not believe that Jesus is the ONLY way to God.

Apparently you do not think you are speaking with someone who knows just a little bit more than you...With all of the love and respect I can muster, son, you're still wet behind the ears. You're still drinking milk, and I've been chewing on meat for years. No disrespect, you're not even in the same ballpark. I'm doing my best to bring you up to speed, but you're fighting it the whole way. Give the controls over to God, stop trying to do it all yourself.

No offense taken! But, I have to laugh though. Not at you, I just thought what you said was very funny! Good one!! That out the way, lets discuss the core fundaments of the Bible. Again, I wish to show you where you've been in err for 25 years.

Quote:
why would you go on thinking that you know what God wants, when you're just a man?

That is the question I asked of you. I know what God wants me to do, what He wants all of His children to do. But I do not pretend to know what goes on in His mind. For you to imply you do, when your little pea brain and my little pea brain together aren't big enough to hold a tiny fraction of His thought?

I agree with you here - I dont know the mind of God. I just know what he wants me to do. Again, he revealed it in his word. He wants me to preach the truth to all that they will believe and come to the Savior, that they may be forgiven of their sins, and have eternal life.

Quote:
Will a finite man, without a reverlation from God, ever know what an infinite God wants of him?

A revelation from God? Are you saying you hear voices in your head? If not, and you mean the revelation of God's word, the Bible, it is still YOUR INTERPRETATION of what the word says. Have you considered that maybe, just maybe, YOUR INTERPRETATION may not be the correct one? I think of that, everyday. I hone my sword sparring with people like you for fun.

Yelling are we? I hope you're not getting fustrated with me. I ask that you have patience with me, as you know, I've only been walking with the Lord for 2 years now. That said, I've heard the "maybe you're interpreatation wrong" statement many times by people who dont know what the Bible says. I'll tell you what I've told them - "I do not interprete the Bible. Instead, I let the scritptures interprete themselves. And, with the help of the Holy Spirit, I know the truth that God wants me to know, because it lines up with his words in scripture. In 25 years of reading the Bible, have you actually found out what exactly the Bible reveals?

Quote:
But ofcourse, this is just my own thoughts and beliefs, based off a book that claims to be God's words. And, you know what? I could in fact be wrong!

I see the words, but I don't think you mean them. You do not fully appreciate, down to your marrow, what your words mean. That much is evident all through your posts. Even if we accept the English Bible as infallible, it is still subject to our individual interpretation. Two examples (answer them both correctly and I'll get off your case): What does the word "divers", as found in the King James Bible, mean? Jacques Cousteau it ain't. Why are the words in italics?

Of course I could be wrong. Just because I dont believe I am wrong, doesnt mean that I dont consider the possiblity of me being wrong. You know? That said, I have no idea what you're talking about with "divers" and "Jacques Cousteau." Whats your point? About the Bible being subject to indivisual interpretation though. Yes, I agree. And, I believe this is the mistake people make when reading the Bible. The Bible is not a book to be subjected to human reasoning, or interpration. Rather, it is the plain truth that God wants us to know. If we truely are born again, the Bible says, we will KNOW what God wants us to know. This is a supernatual occurence given to us by a supernatual God, when we become born again. If we're not born again, we'll vainly go about thinking we know what God says. PLEASE NOTE: Im NOT IN ANYWAY insinuating that you're not born agian. Im not in the business of judging someone's salvation. That said, I do believe you have somethings very twisted!

OK all that said, I have a request. Can you and I discuss the Bible? I want to see what your thoughts are on the core essientials, e.g., Jesus being the only way to God, the Godhead (Trinity), Salvation through grace, Heaven, hell, etc. If you want, we can start with discussing Jesus being the only way to God.

Thanks!
Tell you what, I'll be around. You will find my posts all over this site. Look back in the archives, you'll find all kinds of juicy things. If you don't know the word "divers", you have not read the KJV. And if you don't know why the words are in italics, there is no sense us talking any further. Get another glass of milk, it's good for the bones.
 
"Get another glass of milk, it's good for the bones."

Yeah, good advice. Im still young, I guess my bones are still growing? Umm...What do old people use again? :cool:
 
Conscience said:
"Get another glass of milk, it's good for the bones."

Yeah, good advice. Im still young, I guess my bones are still growing? Umm...What do old people use again? :cool:
Whiskey, lemon and honey...(perfect cough medicine to put ailing babes to bed), so old folks can have a moment of peace...:D

You walked right into that one my friend...

v/r

Q
 
LOL! So, it seems that Im giving the senior citizens some new life. That's gotta be a good thing! Perhaps I should change my name from Conscience to Viagra?
 
Conscience said:
LOL! So, it seems that Im giving the senior citizens some new life. That's gotta be a good thing! Perhaps I should change my name from Conscience to Viagra?
Naw...the stuff's only good for about four hours...
 
Kind Regards Conscience!

I see you still don't quite get it, but at least you are trying.

Besides the fact I had to get up early the next morning to go to work, the part that irked me is that you admit to not reading, let alone trying to understand, what was written directly to you, or indirectly about you. All of your questions, about Jesus being the ONLY way, etc, are already answered, multiple times. You just don't want to read, or try to understand (no one is asking you to accept). So, what you were really telling me is not that you wanted to discuss these things, but that you wanted to tell me these things from your point of view, in some vain hope of convincing me to your way of thinking. Yet, if you had read what I wrote to you, and about you, you would understand already that I know, intimately, where you are coming from. God has taken me light years away from there. Not the devil. Not my own understanding. The Holy Spirit has brought me to a place of understanding far far away from where you are now. I have grown. I no longer require the milk in the word. A little sip now and then is fine, but I do not survive on the stuff. I chew on the meat of the word, the deeper understandings.

If you are not familiar with the word "divers" in the KJV, then you have not read it, plain and simple. The word is used repeatedly all through the old and new testaments. And I struggled with it for about two years, trying to figure out what it meant. And I'm a pretty smart guy, not bragging. I'm still not going to tell you what it means, that is for you to figure out. When you do, you will realize the KJV is written in Elizabethan English, which for intents and purposes is a foreign language. Even for english readers, it is difficult under the best of circumstances to understand. Yet, you know what it says....hmmm. Scholars have argued for centuries, and you have them all beat. No sir, you have your interpretation. That interpretation is not a bad thing, that is what the Holy Spirit has illuminated for you. Your interpretation may not be (and in this case, it is not) valid for me. I love you as a brother, and I tolerate your interpretation. I will not be a stumbling block to your growth and development. If you are willing, I will assist as I can in your growth. If you are not willing, I will not waste my effort, it is too valuable and can be better used where it is appreciated, all to God's glory.

If you do not understand why certain words are in the KJV in italics, which is a little bit harder question, then you are not a student of the Bible. You are a mynah bird, a parrot, a record player. You mimic what you believe the words say. The problem is, and the translators wrote about this to the King and the people in the original edition of the KJV in 1611 AD, is that the original manuscripts (called the Textus Receptus, I recently learned here at this forum) do not translate well into english. I still will not tell you why the words are in italics, that is for you to discover.

These things I tell you are Biblical, they are not inventions to discredit or overthrow the Bible. It is the reality behind the Bible version I am most familiar with, and most Christians of my acquaintance are familiar with. These things do not cast doubt on the Bible. They cast doubt on our personal interpretations of the Bible. It is very easy to have and hold a mistaken interpretation, not realizing for years.

If you will not hear these things from me, that is fine. Look into them yourself. If you do not trust me, or somehow think I am trying to sway you to the "dark side," find some way to discover these things for yourself in a way you do trust. Once you do, come back and tell me what you discover. I will be glad to hear it. I'm afraid that until then, I will presume my words are falling on deaf ears, so I need not waste my breath.
 
Interesting gift, Juan.;)


v/r

Q

juantoo3...

attachment.php


:D
 
Last edited:
Great post, Juan!

"Method" v. "Message."

I moderate other forums and often see this problem arise: a poster with very strong convictions earnestly seeks to convert others to his or her way of thinking. Not that there's anything necessarily wrong with that, but when it occurs in a way that demonstrates that the poster isn't reading others' perspectives and is not interested in any actual dialogue, it comes across as preaching and it grinds discussions to a halt if not moderated.

The response this type of poster often recceives is the result of frustration from other forum participants because there is no real exchange of ideas and no dialogue. The poster, however, doesn't hear the criticism as directed toward his or her method, but perceives any criticism as directed toward his or her message. Which it isn't. Ironically, this mis-perception of the criticism often drives the poster to engage in an ever more severe cycle of the very behavior that is frustrating other forum participants. If not carefully moderated, it gets out of hand very quickly.

Proselytizing

This forum serves host to a sophisticated, extremely diverse, and well-read community when it comes to topics of religion, science, philosophy and spirituality. I doubt there is anyone who hasn't heard the basic "gospel" message of mainstream Christianity. Some accept that message as their primary worldview. Some do not. Some think very critically about it and are in the process of understanding its meaning for themselves. And some don't care at all, because it simply isn't a tradition they are interested in. However, attempting to proselytize on an interfaith discussion forum is inevitably going to be perceived as rude and condescending. The irritation expressed in response isn't necessarily a disagreement with the message being presented. If there is some idea that a person disagrees with, I would imagine they would point out what they disagree with if they are so inclined, and a dialogue can begin on a certain issue or claim.

Regardless, peppering a forum with posts that don't really seek a discussion is probably not going to achieve the poster's goals. And responding to criticism's of one's methods with accusations that one is being persecuted for his or her ideas will not not rectify the basic problem.

I commend the moderators on this forum for their excellent work in keeping the discussion open, but respectful. A great discussion forum only works because of the hard work and dedication of people like Juan and Q.

Thanks.
 
The title of this thread got my attention, though noticed most of the succeeding dialogue was about competing "truth" claims, some of whose pages i skipped!:p Thought i'd respond to the apparent intent of its title with a quotation from Brother David Steindl-Rast, that wonderful contemporary contemplative (and integrative) Christian writer. In an interview he was asked if ever in his "moments of truth" he though he had "the Truth" and he responded:

"The key question is not one concerning objective 'facts out there,' but a deeply personal question addressed to the heart of each of us. The question is what is your attitude towards truth? When you think of truth, is your foremost desire to 'grasp it?' Are you convinced the truth is something you can have, possess, hold firmly in one's hand as it were? If the answer is more or less 'yes,' that's where your problem comes from.

Try to look at it with fresh eyes. Remember your own deepest experiences. In your moments of truth, is it ever correct to say that you have the truth? does that truly reflect your experience? Wouldn't you rather say in those moments that the truth has you? You stand under it when you truly understand. But, it is not 'standing' strictly speaking; it is a dynamic movement. St. Paul speaks of 'doing truth in love.' That is a far cry from grasping. Truth is something we discover by carrying it out. It is not a list of statements, but a direction of life. What we grasp of truth is necessarily always partial and limited. No matter how huge your hands and firm your grip, you can only hold so much. The right inner attitude toward truth is not expressed by the grasping hand only, but by the open hand, capable of receiving what e.e.cummings calls 'illimitable reality'...Yes, there many given facts we have to grasp. But mere grasping of facts will lead us at best to the accumulation of knowledge. What our heart really longs for is wisdom. And wisdom is found when we not only grab and use reality, but when we let it grab us, savor it, let it speak to us and so reveal its deep meaning...There is no room here for grasping, but all the room in the world for responding."

Have a good one, Earl
 
Beautiful! Thank you so much Earl, I have only read his commentary on Meister Eckhart, the title I believe was Meister Eckhart, From whom God Hid Nothing, or something close to that. Could you please post the title of other works of his for us?

Thank you!
 
Back
Top