Happiness is achieved through Meaning

coberst

Well-Known Member
Messages
427
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Happiness is achieved through Meaning

I suspect that when parents are asked what are the most meaningful things in your life they will answer “My kids are the most meaningful things in my life”. A kid might say anything when asked the same question. It may be their car, their boy friend, their new hair style, their new bike, etc. The parent has had more time and experiences about which to organize what is meaningful in their life than does a kid.

The great truth of the nineteenth century was that produced by William Dilthey, which was the answer to the question “what do humans constantly strive for?” “It was “meaning” said Dilthey, meaning is the great truth about human nature.

“Everything that lives, lives by drawing together strands of experience as a basis for its action; to live is to act, to move forward into the world of experience…]b]Meaning is the relationship between parts of experience[/b].”

Man does not do this drawing together on the basis of simple experience but on the basis of concepts. Sapiens impose symbolic categories of thought on raw experience. Her conception of life determines the manner in which s/he values all of its parts.

Concludes Dilthey, meaning “is the comprehensive category through which life becomes comprehensible…Man is the meaning-creating animal.”

What are some of the fundamental considerations we must focus upon when we speak of creating meaning?

Meaning is an abstract concept. What is an abstract concept? Webster informs me that concept is defined as “an abstract or generic idea generalized from particular instances”. I would say that there are two types of ideas, i.e. concepts: concrete (generic) and abstract.

A concrete concept is the neural network that is created in the brain when we have a physical experience. An abstract concept is constructed, often unconsciously, by one or more concrete concepts. An abstract idea might usefully be thought of as similar to a molecule. The molecule is made up of one or more atoms and the abstract concept is made up of one or more concrete concepts. That is to say the conceptual and inference structure of a concrete concept is mapped into the “mental space” containing the abstract concept.

The concrete concept is an “objective” concept while the abstract concept is a “subjective concept”.

Examples of objective concepts becoming part of subjective concepts:

Infant feeling warm when held mapping into subjective concept of affection.
Sensing a foul smell into abstract idea of a movie “that stinks”.
Sensing the rise of milk while pouring into a measuring cup leading to a subjective judgment that prices are too high.

We are meaning creating creatures. We are creatures who create abstract ideas about which we live, die, and kill. Our task is to comprehend this fact and through the sophistication thus achieved we may be able to create abstract concepts suitable to permit our survival for a few more centuries.
 
Meaning is fundamental. Truth and falsity are species of meaning. Meaning begins when we select from the vast universe something upon which we focus our attention.

Iraq may be slightly meaningful to me until my grandson informs me that he has joined the army. At that moment Iraq has taken a giant step in meaningfulness to me.
 
Meaning has great meaning for me.:)

Meaning comes from an investigation of what one actually obtains when symbols are converted to "things" or concrete actions.

Chris
 
Like most words the word "meaning" has more than one definition. I would add the following as being the other definition of "meaning".


“Everything that lives, lives by drawing together strands of experience as a basis for its action; to live is to act, to move forward into the world of experience…Meaning is the relationship between parts of experience.”


Philosophy has chosen your defintion of the word and SGCS has introduced another and fundamentally differnt definition of the word.


The two views provide a totally different world for us to think about.
 
Interesting. Would you say, then, that happiness comes from the flavor of one's sense of continuity in life? I know I'm happiest when I have the feeling that all my ducks are in a row, all my bases are covered, and the currents of what you're calling "experience" running through my life seem logically contiguous and manageable.

Chris
 
Hey Chris,

I know I feel happy when everything goes according to my expectations too. As a matte of fact I work hard so that things go that way as much as possible. Of course then there is the flip side of it isn't there.
We both know the rest of the story since we have talked at length about attachment, Buddhism's eight worldly concerns and all, but let's face it: happiness is always fleeting, and to me is to be enjoyed when it's here.

If we surmise there is no inherent meaning in anything except that which we impute, could we not be happy by design? Isn't this the real underpinning of all religion and philosophy to include things like hedonism?
 
Interesting. Would you say, then, that happiness comes from the flavor of one's sense of continuity in life? I know I'm happiest when I have the feeling that all my ducks are in a row, all my bases are covered, and the currents of what you're calling "experience" running through my life seem logically contiguous and manageable.

Chris

It is meaningful to you that you have the ducks in a row and your bases covered. Thus it makes you happy.

What makes me happy is the search for answers to the question "Why do humans do the things they do and can we do better".

I have been on the trail for more than 25 years. Thus you might say that you and I differ fundamentally in what is meaningful.
 
If we surmise there is no inherent meaning in anything except that which we impute, could we not be happy by design? Isn't this the real underpinning of all religion and philosophy to include things like hedonism?

Well...yeah! I guess it could. Perhaps that's why the pursuit of happiness is supposed to be a self evident right.

Chris
 
Happiness is a warm gun

Mother superior jump the gun......


Mother superior jump the gun


Mother superior jump the gun


Mother...............................
 

Concludes Dilthey, meaning “is the comprehensive category through which life becomes comprehensible…Man is the meaning-creating animal.”

Is it meaning or the activity of creating it that is satisfying?

Aristotle said the use of the mind is the highest good. The actual products may not always be what's important. Some people just like the process.
 
Is it meaning or the activity of creating it that is satisfying?

Aristotle said the use of the mind is the highest good. The actual products may not always be what's important. Some people just like the process.

Let us take the word "Iraq". Some time in my life "Iraq" became meaningful to me because I became conscious of it. Out of all the things in the universe I became conscious of a concept that is named Iraq and in so doing this word referred to a concept that I was conscious of and thereby it, the concept, became meaningful to me.

Several years ago America invades Iraq and the concept begins to load up with all kinds of concepts from my experiences. That is to say the meaning of Iraq grows in importance.

A few weeks ago my grandson tells me he is joining the army. Bang, Iraq now becomes a priority meaning to me.
 
Back
Top