Student seeking knowledge

student77

New Member
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I am a college student writing a paper about Christianity, it is a comparative paper. I am looking for someone to answer some questions about Christianity for me from the Christian point of view. The information from the questions will be used to help me provide material to my paper and to give me a Christian perspective for my studies.

If there is someone on this forum that would like to help me out please let me know and I will post my questions.

Thank you
 
Well, what are your questions? (Please understand that you will probably get different answers from different Christians. There is a great deal of diversity to be found within Christianity.)
 
Welcome to CR, student77.
I am a college student writing a paper about Christianity, it is a comparative paper. I am looking for someone to answer some questions about Christianity for me from the Christian point of view. The information from the questions will be used to help me provide material to my paper and to give me a Christian perspective for my studies.

If there is someone on this forum that would like to help me out please let me know and I will post my questions.
I suppose a lot depends on the nature of your questions, but go ahead and give it a try. We aren't generally keen on doing your homework for you though, you do need to put in some effort of your own. So if your questions are a bit too generic or broad, we might direct you to some studies of your own. We'll just have to play it by ear and see what questions you've got.
 
Are you looking for knowledge of the bible , OR knowledge of traditions and manmade doctrines.?


because the mainstream religions of christendom are believe it or not quite different to what the bible REALLY teaches.


many things in the mainstream of christendom are as you will find not inline with what the bible REALLY teaches.


so i suppose it is what you are after, are you after bible teaching ,or teachings of men.

because there are both out there, teachings of men ,and
TRUE BIBLE TEACHINGS

:)SEEK AND YOU WILL FIND:)



after all christianity should be inline with what the bible REALLY teaches, and what Jesus himself taught, but as the bible itself informs us , way back in the times of the early congregations many teachings of men made there way into the congregations.

The Word of God is true and that is our measuring rod.


1 Timothy 4 says that in later periods of time some would fall away from the faith, paying attention to misleading inspired utterances and teachings of demons by the hypocrisy of men who speak lies.


make no mistake about it , many lies have been going on for centuries , and many have got to believe those lies, so that now, people are even believing that those lies are the truth.


People who have righteous hearts and love true doctrine and righteousness are taking up the pure worship of Almighty God, Jehovah, studying his Word and seeking to do his will.

They are defending themselves against lies. On the other hand, there are those who prefer to choose lies and who base their worship on falsehoods



choices choices choices:)

Paul spoke of a falling away that would take place.
He said that "the inspired utterance says definitely that in later periods of time some will fall away from the faith." (1 Tim. 4:1)

Today that great falling away from walking in the footsteps of Christ Jesus is at its height.

It was so important for Paul to say to the Christians of his time
Pay constant attention to yourself and to your teaching.

and he went on to say,

Stay by these things, for by doing this you will save both yourself and those who listen to you.
This is even more applicable today.
No individual professing to be a Christian can brush aside the teachings of Christ.
The Holy Bible is God’s Word.
Jesus believed it and lived it.
Every professed follower of his must pay constant attention to himself and to Christ’s teachings so that he may stay awake .



Jesus introduced the wonderful message of the kingdom of the heavens and it must still be preached.

It is still the only hope for mankind.
Jesus taught his followers to pray "Let your kingdom come. Let your will come to pass, as in heaven, also upon earth." (Matt. 6:10)


True followers of Christ are still preaching the good news of God’s kingdom as the only hope for mankind and they believe it with all their heart, mind, soul and strength, and they are on the watch as to the time when God’s established kingdom with all its powerful heavenly force will strike and step into the affairs of men
MATTHEW 24;14
DANIEL 2;44
MATTHEW 28;19-20


 
Thank you to those of you that have replied to my post. I am surely not looking for anyone to do my homework for me, I am genuinely interested in the perspective of practicing Christians with respect to the questions that I have. The paper that I am writing is part question and answer summary so that I have the point of view and understanding of todays practicing religious participants and believers; part research with compare and contrast of another religion. I have Chosen Christianity, particularly the Catholic denomination, as the subject for my paper. I am open to all view points however, so Catholic or non-Catholic Christians please feel free to reply. You will notice that my questions were written for the Catholic view point, but I do want to hear from others too, as I am sure other denominations also have specific practices and understandings of these questions.

The very simple reason I have Chosen Christianity is that I do not practice any religion, however, many in my family do practice some form of Christianity and I would like a better understanding of it, not just the secular understanding that I currently view it from. I do understand that even within religions there are different denominations, understandings, interpretations, points of view and opinions; I am looking for that, I am interested to see the differences even within one particular religion.

I greatly appreciate any and all help that I recieve with this, and I have posted my questions below. I respectfully look forward to the answers that I will recieve from all who reply.

1) How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?
2) What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?
3) How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian denominations? I know that there are many similarities.
4) What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism?
5) How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ?
6) What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?
7) I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?
8) What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?
9) Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?
10) Why is it so important that priests not marry?
11) Why can’t women become priests?
12) What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
13) What is the significance of Baptism?
14) Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children at birth?
15) What is a Rosary for?
16) What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it?
17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?
18) Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?
19) Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world
20) Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?

Thank you all for the answers that I recieve.
 
Are you looking for knowledge of the bible , OR knowledge of traditions and manmade doctrines.?


because the mainstream religions of christendom are believe it or not quite different to what the bible REALLY teaches.


many things in the mainstream of christendom are as you will find not inline with what the bible REALLY teaches.


so i suppose it is what you are after, are you after bible teaching ,or teachings of men.

because there are both out there, teachings of men ,and
TRUE BIBLE TEACHINGS

:)SEEK AND YOU WILL FIND:)



after all christianity should be inline with what the bible REALLY teaches, and what Jesus himself taught, but as the bible itself informs us , way back in the times of the early congregations many teachings of men made there way into the congregations.

The Word of God is true and that is our measuring rod.


1 Timothy 4 says that in later periods of time some would fall away from the faith, paying attention to misleading inspired utterances and teachings of demons by the hypocrisy of men who speak lies.


make no mistake about it , many lies have been going on for centuries , and many have got to believe those lies, so that now, people are even believing that those lies are the truth.


People who have righteous hearts and love true doctrine and righteousness are taking up the pure worship of Almighty God, Jehovah, studying his Word and seeking to do his will.

They are defending themselves against lies. On the other hand, there are those who prefer to choose lies and who base their worship on falsehoods



choices choices choices:)

Paul spoke of a falling away that would take place.
He said that "the inspired utterance says definitely that in later periods of time some will fall away from the faith." (1 Tim. 4:1)

Today that great falling away from walking in the footsteps of Christ Jesus is at its height.

It was so important for Paul to say to the Christians of his time
Pay constant attention to yourself and to your teaching.

and he went on to say,

Stay by these things, for by doing this you will save both yourself and those who listen to you.
This is even more applicable today.
No individual professing to be a Christian can brush aside the teachings of Christ.
The Holy Bible is God’s Word.
Jesus believed it and lived it.
Every professed follower of his must pay constant attention to himself and to Christ’s teachings so that he may stay awake .



Jesus introduced the wonderful message of the kingdom of the heavens and it must still be preached.

It is still the only hope for mankind.
Jesus taught his followers to pray "Let your kingdom come. Let your will come to pass, as in heaven, also upon earth." (Matt. 6:10)


True followers of Christ are still preaching the good news of God’s kingdom as the only hope for mankind and they believe it with all their heart, mind, soul and strength, and they are on the watch as to the time when God’s established kingdom with all its powerful heavenly force will strike and step into the affairs of men
MATTHEW 24;14
DANIEL 2;44
MATTHEW 28;19-20


Love of truth is an ever-burning fire in the mind, which is too easily extinguished by the arrogance of imagining oneself to be always in the right. Belittling one's neighbor's beliefs, is the arrogance of a fool.
 
1) 1)How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?
2) For me, Christianity has given me a purpose driven life. Though there is an ultimate goal, there is the encouragement to view the scenery along the way, and know it was placed there just for you.
2)What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?
3) God, is a mysterious friend and Father. Though it is not understood clearly, his existence is expressed in a “trinity” or three personages, one Godhead. This God made us to commune with him, and apparently has a great deal of patience with us, to that end.
3)How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian denominations? I know that there are many similarities.
4) The Catholic Christian (it is one and the same), enjoys a great deal of tradition, and mystery. However, the core beliefs are identical to that of other mainstream Christian denominations. (Trinity, Jesus resurrection and payment for our sins, the gift of salvation, and our responsibility to make use of that gift for the benefit of others).
4)What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism?
5) Christmas, Lent, Easter, Pentacost, Ascention, and various other holidays pertaining to the Catholic denomination.
5)How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ?
6) Wherein other denominations give quiet nod to events that are recognized, Catholics go one step further, usually by attending mass or fasting or going out of their way to do something (such as charity work)
6)What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?
7) Christmas is “Christ’s mass”. It heralds in the celebration of the birth of the Savior of man. It is an awe inspiring time of reflection on what was done for all of us (including you). The commercialism of Christmas is fun, but not the primary reason for celebrating.
8) Easter, is the acknowledgement of the pain that man causes God, and for the conscientious, the sorrow that accompanies the acknowledgement. But it is also the joy that such a God would deliver us from ourselves and be victorious over death, in order to bring us back to Him.
7)I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?
9) Lent, acknowledges the 40 days that Christ spent fasting in the wilderness/desert, prior to Satan’s temptations of a weakened Jesus. It is the perior of 40 weekdays before Easter observed in some Christian churches as a period of prayer, penance, fasting and self-denial. It starts on Ash Wednesday in Western Churches.8)What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?
10) Debauchery, and goofy fun prior to the seriousness of lent. Some say it is the nature of man, before he accepts Christ and becomes a new man (leaving his natural state behind him).
9)Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?
11) All food is sacred, as it is a gift from God. Bread and Wine at mass become body and blood of Christ (in most Christian denominations it “represents” the body and blood of Christ during communion). To Catholics, it becomes literally the body and blood of Christ. We look at it this way because of the words Jesus spoke to his disciples during the breaking of the bread at the “Last Supper” He said “This is my Body, this is my blood, do this in memory of me.”
10)Why is it so important that priests not marry?
12) The argument for catholics here is that a wife and family would distract a priest or a huband, a nun from fully dedicating themselves to God and his work for them. This is not a shared view from other catholic churches such as the Anglicans, or Episcopalians, who have married priests and nuns.
11)Why can’t women become priests?
13) In the Roman Catholic church, Peter and Paul’s statements are used to point out that woman caused the fall of man, because she was beguiled by the serpent. It is also argued that the first counsel in order to secure a patriarchal structure, banned women from being priests in the Roman Catholic church. This did not apparently apply to the Irish Catholic church (at least not for about 300 years). Genesis also states that woman shall desire after man, and he shall rule over her. In matters of faith over the community, it is the male that presides. In matters of faith in the home, it is the female that presides with her children. It gets very complicated and is contentious at best among people.
12)What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
14) Mass comes from the desire to celebrate the mystery of God and his goodness and sacrifice to man. Communion is a means by which to remember exactly what the cost was to save man (from himself).
13)What is the significance of Baptism?
15) To Catholics and other Christian denominations, Baptism is a promise to live a Christ like life (or to raise a child in a Christ like life). It is an announcement to the world of the parents’ or the baptized’s intention. It comes from when John the Baptist began his service prior to the arrival of Jesus. Jesus then cemented the concept when he submitted to being baptized by John, in which the bible says the Father found great pleasure in Jesus’ submission to this ritual, and the meaning behind it. It means a man dies to his old ways, and comes from the water fresh and clean and new.
14)Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children at birth?
16) See the above…
15)What is a Rosary for?
17) During the Crusades, the knights went many places, and discovered many faiths toward’s God. In some areas of the world, they discovered people using “worry beads” as a way to focus on God, and not be distracted by the outside world. These knights took these worry beads back to the pope who saw wisdom in their use to help focus a man’s mind on God. So the church adopted the concept with Christ, The Father, The Holy Spirit, and the virgin mother at the center of the purpose for using the “rosary”.
16)What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it?
18) Confirmation is just that, a person confirming before the populace that their intention is to follow the ways of Christ.They acknowledge they will live as a Christian.
17)What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?
19) Many, lol. Take a look at the world around you. There are so many temptations, and naysayers. There are people who hate Christians for various reasons. There are things we’d love to do, but know they are wrong for us to do. There is the issue of dealing with wrath (rage), greed, laziness, gluttony, lust, envy and pride. And then there is actually believing that we are saved (self doubt), even though we accept Christ’s gift of salvation. There is also guilt that we never express to others, but we all have it inside us.
18)Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?
20) Who else has ever said to man “I don’t care who you are, what you are, how bad you’ve been, how dirty you look, how disfigured you are, how hateful you’ve been, how damaged you are, what you’ve done…I love you and want you with me, forever.” ????
19)Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world
21) Judaism is first. It contains the founding principals upon which the three (some say four with Ba’hai faith), faiths come from. Some would argue that Islam almost began with the birth of Ishmael (Abraham’s first born son). But Ishmael let go the opportunity. Issac did not, and Judaism took off. After Christ’s resurrection and ascension into heaven (according to the bible), Judaism and the new Christians were for the most part, part of the same faith. When Saul of Taursus observed and approved the stoning to death of Stephen some seven years after Christ, the two split. On the way to Damascus, Saul was blinded and according to scripture met Christ, became a convert to the Christian way, and that widened the split into two similar but separate faiths. Christianity is definitely based on Judaism. Islam came 600 years later, when Mohammed had revelations and instructed scribes to write what he saw. There is an argument out there that goes: Mohammed wanted the Jews and Christians to get together with his visions and form a SUPER FAITH between the three. He believed his was the last point needed in order to make the correct belief in God, reality. Of course the other two faiths declined. Hence the third monotheistic faith of the times began.
20)Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?
22) There is lot’s of information you lack, and I fear it would take you a whole volume of books to get every detail. But, this should help you find what you are looking for (it’s a start).

Thank you all for the answers that I recieve.

You’re welcome.

v/r

Q
 
Hi Student77

I'm not Catholic but do have Christian interests unrelated to Christendom which for some reason is now come to be called Christianity. I can only then answer certain questions from an ancient Christian perspective..

1) How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?


It has revealed both the existence of and the path leading to the way towards the "objective good". In this way it has revealed objective human meaning and purpose.

2) What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?

God does not exist. God "IS." Existence is in time and space. We exist so God is incomprehensible for us. God as "ONE" is outside of time and space. God's influence existing within time and space is as THREE or as lawful results of the Trinity.

6) What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?

Our increased acceptance of imagination allows secularism to take hold so naturally the meaning of Christmas and Easter must be secularized into oblivion at the societal level.

9) Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?

Certain foods and drink contain an abundance of nutrients needed for nourishing our supernatural part and others tend to drain it.

17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?


Christianity is the struggle with oneself. We all have our own acquired demons and they fight for their life.

18) Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?

Because the essence of Christianity is a truth worth prostituting.

[SIZE=-1]
[SIZE=-1]Fool’s gold exists because there is real gold. –Rumi.[/SIZE]
[/SIZE]


The essence of Christianity is real gold leaving much opportunity for many forms of fool's gold including violent expressions of Christendom.

19) Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world

They are different teachings to blend with human types and societal structure natural for arising on different parts of the earth.


However their devolution and associated hostility is a natural result of the human condition. We are an inner plurality living under the illusion that we are "one." As a plurality we are in opposition to ourselves and we reconcile it through imagination. Religious hostility is the result of differing imaginary reconciliation's.

20) Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?

Two essential questions you must consider:

1. Matthew 22

21"Caesar's," they replied.
Then he said to them, "Give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's."

How does one tell the difference? There is a difference between a Christian response and the the more usual response from Christendom.

2. John 12

23Jesus replied, "The hour has come for the Son of Man to be glorified. 24I tell you the truth, unless a kernel of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it remains only a single seed. But if it dies, it produces many seeds. 25The man who loves his life will lose it, while the man who hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life. 26Whoever serves me must follow me; and where I am, my servant also will be. My Father will honor the one who serves me.

This is the essence of Christianity. If you want to write a paper on Christianity, you must ponder its depth to give meaning to your paper..
 
Hi Student77

I'm not Catholic but do have Christian interests unrelated to Christendom which for some reason is now come to be called Christianity. I can only then answer certain questions from an ancient Christian perspective..




It has revealed both the existence of and the path leading to the way towards the "objective good". In this way it has revealed objective human meaning and purpose.



God does not exist. God "IS." Existence is in time and space. We exist so God is incomprehensible for us. God as "ONE" is outside of time and space. God's influence existing within time and space is as THREE or as lawful results of the Trinity.



Our increased acceptance of imagination allows secularism to take hold so naturally the meaning of Christmas and Easter must be secularized into oblivion at the societal level.



Certain foods and drink contain an abundance of nutrients needed for nourishing our supernatural part and others tend to drain it.

17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?


Christianity is the struggle with oneself. We all have our own acquired demons and they fight for their life.



Because the essence of Christianity is a truth worth prostituting.



The essence of Christianity is real gold leaving much opportunity for many forms of fool's gold including violent expressions of Christendom.



They are different teachings to blend with human types and societal structure natural for arising on different parts of the earth.


However their devolution and associated hostility is a natural result of the human condition. We are an inner plurality living under the illusion that we are "one." As a plurality we are in opposition to ourselves and we reconcile it through imagination. Religious hostility is the result of differing imaginary reconciliation's.



Two essential questions you must consider:

1. Matthew 22



How does one tell the difference? There is a difference between a Christian response and the the more usual response from Christendom.

2. John 12



This is the essence of Christianity. If you want to write a paper on Christianity, you must ponder its depth to give meaning to your paper..
And then there are those who like nothing more than to destroy, for the pleasure of it...
 
1) How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life? I trust him completely, so i don't fear what is to come, and i am led in my life by the spirit. Whether something good happens or something bad happens or when nothing is happening, i glorify God and this causes me to not be angry or worried or discontent. Because the spirit is with me, i cannot go down roads that lead to sin, i get resistance. God's word gives me wisdom in everyday situations, and it gives me peace though my prayers, and it gives me love in my spiritual connection with God. I have high self-esteem and self-worth because my Father is King.

2) What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?
God loves all his creations and reaches out to us in his triune nature and we are to love each other as he has loved us, and this love stems from the internal relationship that is within God that is the Father, Son, Holy Spirit. And although God is Holy and righteous, he is also just and jealous, and can be angered and pleased, he is many things just as we have many sides to us and emotions.

3) How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian denominations? I know that there are many similarities.
There is a basic foundation of Christianity. As it falls on cultures it is embellished with their pre-existing rituals and rites which sometimes is insignificant and other times it conflicts. So catholicism is christianity with embellishments from the Roman civilization.

4) What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism? Important christian holidays are Christmas and Easter, marking the birth of Christ and his resurrection. There are others that christians take part in, or can take part in if they choose to, but these are the most significant. An important tradition is communion where the body of Christ (the church) takes part the symbolic taking in of Christ (his blood and his flesh) until we see him again and partake together in heaven. For christians a holiday is not something one has to follow but chooses to out of love and reflection, but many do this every sunday or even everyday.

5) How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ?
That is the reason why we are different, so God can be worshiped in many different ways, the beauty is in what all people bring to God during their worship of him thru holidays.

6) What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?
Christmas is basically Christ's birthday, and Easter is the day he died for our sins and is how we are know saved by grace if we accept God's salvation. For the love of money, some try to cash in on that which is set aside for God. It is the same reason Christ went to the temple and kicked out all the people trying to make money.

7) I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?
It is a symbolic outward honoring of God borrowed from other cultural traditions. You will see it more in Catholicism because it fell on and picked up on things from other cultures as it spread out and became part of the religion; however, one doesn't have to do anything for others to see it or feel social guilt or think God is displeased, because true worshiping is spiritual.

8) What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?
i think i answered these types of questions already.

9) Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?
All things can be eaten if it is out of necessity, and given their proper respect. Bread and wine are important during communion, because the Lord said they represent his flesh and his blood. There are certain foods; however, but this is more a jewish law given to them by God as they were to seperate themselves from the pagans.

10) Why is it so important that priests not marry?
It is important because to do the work of Christ it can take you away from your family and it is not fair to others.

11) Why can’t women become priests?
Women can be full of the spirit and full of experience and can teach others; however, man has the responsibility to be the head of the family and bring Spirit of God into the home and into the church. It's not that women cant, it's that is men need to.

12) What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
Gather as the body of Christ and worship God because he made us to worship him and to need each other.

13) What is the significance of Baptism?
It is symbolic of being born again just as John the Baptist baptized the Messiah, and fulfilled scripture. It is beautiful and expression of love. More importantly is the spiritual baptism, that is accepting Christ into your heart and giving yourself to him and being born again thru the spirit.

14) Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children at birth?
It is giving your life and your family to God, and it gives the child godparents in case something ever happens to the parents. Later on in life when the child chooses to, he should accept God and be baptized as he understands it and chooses it.

15) What is a Rosary for?
The rosary is used to meditate and pray, many times in repetition, and also to venerate the virgin Mary. however, it is not needed because God already knows what we need before we even say it, so we should pray to Him straight from the heart rather than making it more dramatic than it needs to be. So it is just ornamental with more cultural and traditional significance from roman catholicism than it is necessary in praying and being heard or forgiven, which should only be directed at the Father in his Son's name.

16) What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it?
Steps in learning and understanding God done in rites of initiation.

17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?
To be accepting of others that are not Christian, so that Christianity can be seen and God can work in their lives, rather than being judged and kept at a distance. To realize that christianity is less religion and more relationship. And a big challenge and threat is the emerging church's philoshophy that there are many different ways to God and they are all right.

18) Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?
Christianity was spread by disciples, to different people and from there it creates a ripple effect. Some of it can be attested to evangelism by explorers, even though much of it was done for land and money and power it also brought christianity to many distant lands, God is in control and he is the creator of love and can take things that are bad and turn them into good and many of these colonized countries have become christian even though it was imposed on them, much of it has to do with broken and poor people being more accepting of hope that is found in Christ. Christianity today is spread thru evangelism and unlike times past, is spread for the right reasons, like the disciples did, which is continuing the work of Christ, because God loves them and wants all to know about the salvation in his Son.

19) Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world.
Jesus is the reason we are all different. I dont think these religions all start at the same point either. I think there has always been "christianity" and "judaism" from the beginning with Adam, as he had a personal relationship and walked with God (that is the pre-incarnate Jesus), and he was physically doing what some spiritually do with God today. I believe prophets believed that Christ was coming and their hope was in Him, and I believe also that many had seen Christ and even sat and talked with Him before, during and after he came to us as the Lamb of God. So from the beginning I would say that God has always revealed himself as the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. With that in mind, Jews are the chosen people and it is thru them that the law of God was given, prophets were given, but even more importantly God's grace was given to them thru Jesus Christ. and these same people that always believed and hoped in the messiah became modern day Christians as God's plan unfolded. I think those in Judaism always love God, but dont want to let go of their political power, earthly wealth, and cultural traditions and social acceptance which causes the majority of them to reject the gospel and to reject Christ, but not all of them, as i said before there is and will always be those jews that always believed in and have accepted Jesus and have a personal relationship with God. I think islam wishes to be the chosen people, but are not, and have created stories to replace themselves with Jews. I also think that Judaism and Christianity fell on the pre-existing culture and religions of the arab nations and has transformed itself into Islam, and is no longer what was originally intended by God, but basically incorrect versions of both Judaism (old testament) and Christianity (new testament) which became the quran. So in addition to Jesus as the messiah, I believe some ethnocentrism keeps us apart.

20) Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?
If you think of anything else just ask.

[/quote]
 
Ah, no holds barred, holding nothing back?

First, all the fancy formatting makes it really difficult to quote and respond, just an FYI. I spent 10 minutes cleaning up the formatting to make it easier to respond.

How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?.
It has provided a moral construct by which to guide my life.

What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?.
My view of G-d is very non-traditional, and to be truthful is still "evolving." I haven't sealed my mind at this point to any possibilities regarding the nature of G-d. About the only semi-certainty I hold is that "He" exists, but that is something I intuit and hold by personal experience.

How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian denominations? I know that there are many similarities..

What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism?

How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ?

I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?

What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?

Why is it so important that priests not marry?
You would be best to ask Thomas or Quahom these, or better, look up some of their posts. Thomas in particular, as I believe he is a seminary student and a very learned scholar from the Catholic POV.

What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?
Christmas commemorates the birth of Jesus, Easter is supposed to commemorate the resurrection of Jesus.

Commercialization and secularization take away from the commemoration by diluting the memorial.

Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?
Generally speaking, no, not in the Jewish or Islamic sense (like no pork).

There *are* certain foods that hold symbolism in a particular context, such as the bread and wine at communion.


Why can’t women become priests?
http://www.comparative-religion.com/forum/women-priests-9241.html

A good thread going on now discussing that very subject.

What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
Mass, as I understand, is the Catholic name for what a Protestant would call a worship service. Communion commemorates the sacrifice Jesus made, and provides a unifying rite for the congregation.


What is the significance of Baptism?
To dedicate a person to Christianity.


Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children at birth?
Not all denominations do. While I see nothing disqualifying if a child is baptised, I do side with those would teach that a person should understand the purpose of baptism before being baptised.


What is a Rosary for?
It is my understanding it is a reminder for prayer.


What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it?
It is confirmation in the faith, and that is the importance of it. It is the formal "coming out" ceremony letting the rest of the congregation know you are fully trained in the principles of the faith. This is primarily a Catholic thing.


What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?
None that cannot be overcome by diligence.


Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?
Dunno. G-d's grace and favor? Chance and circumstance? A big ol' can of whoopa$$? Your guess is as good as mine.

Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world?
That's not quite true.

Judaism dates back historically to at least 500 BC, probably much further. Some scholars are happy to grant at least 1000 BC. Christianity wasn't formally incorporated until 324 AD, prior to that it was a red-headed step child of Judaism. Islam came about sometime in the 600's AD. This stuff can be found on WIKI easily enough.

Traditionally, and somewhat historically, both Islam and Christianity grew out of Judaism. Islam with Ishmael, Christianity with Jesus. Again, easy to find on WIKI.


Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?
I have no way to know what is significant or important to you with so little information.

Thank you all for the answers that I recieve.
You are welcome.
 
...You would be best to ask Thomas or Quahom these, or better, look up some of their posts. Thomas in particular, as I believe he is a seminary student and a very learned scholar from the Catholic POV...
The "priest and the sailor" eh? Thanks. lol ;)
 
Hello, Student, and welcome to CR! I'll have a go at this, but I'm not Catholic, nor am I a "mainstream" Christian in many ways. I follow Christ's teachings and I do attend an Episcopal church when I attend church, but in practice I combine a modern variety of my ancestral tradition (Druidry) with Christ's teachings. While a bit unusual, I am not the only one. Just a bit of background so you will understand if my answers are a bit different than others...

1) How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?
Christianity has not shaped my life much. But Christ has shaped it enormously. Christ's teachings profoundly shape my ethics and feeling of purpose in life, and my experience of Christ spiritually gives me comfort, strength, peace, joy, and love. Eventually, I came to a comfortable place in the Episcopal church as it is a church that is mostly unified by practice (i.e., praying together, singing together, kneeling together, etc.) rather than by doctrine. That works for me. There is a strength and energetic amplification when multiple people come together in Christ, so over time I came to appreciate the value of a religious community along with individual spiritual practice.
2) What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?
I'm a panentheist. Panentheism means that I believe God is in all things and beyond all things. So I fundamentally believe in a God that is both immanent (within and around us in other beings and Nature) and transcendent (beyond what is comprehensible). While such a view is not doctrinally common, it is remarkably common among Christian individuals, especially from the Celtic-influenced strains of the faith. I both am and am not a trinitarian. What I mean by that is that I believe there is a meaning and value in the concept of the Trinity, but I do not think we can define God. So I do not view the Trinity as a definition of God (i.e., the way God is) but rather I see the Trinity as a valuable way for us to embrace the mystery of God and to understand the relationship of Love. Threes are very important in both Druidry and Christianity, because three is the number of relationships- two individuals and a connection between. For example, the Trinity points to an incomprehensible Creator (Father), an immanent Spirit (The Holy Spirit), and a bridge between humanity and Creator (Christ). It is about connection to me, and that's valuable. But I don't think that God can be defined. I believe that God is One, and we can only experience glimpses of God. I just believe my mind is too puny to understand the vastness of what God is.
3) How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian denominations? I know that there are many similarities.
For the most part, it seems that Protestant denominations tend to decentralize power, though they all differ in how they make decisions. I would think you could find out a lot about the similarities and differences online by browsing many of the major denominations' websites and reading up on how they make decisions, their key elements of their statements of faith, and their organizational structure.
4) What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism?
I think most Christians see the big two as Christmas and Easter. I don't find holidays that important, to be honest. I believe faith should be lived as if every day is equally important. But I like the holidays because they are fun celebrations. I really liked my last Anglican church (I moved :()- they had a great holiday called the Kirkin' O' the Tartans where the priest blessed everyone's kilts and other tartans for the year. They also celebrated St. Francis Day and everyone brought their pets in for a blessing.
5) How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ?
You'd have to ask a Catholic person, I suppose. I can say that some Christian denominations don't celebrate the holidays at all, or do so in a very limited manner. JW's don't celebrate Christmas, I think- you should ask mee.
6) What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?
I don't think commercialization does affect the Christian meaning unless a person allows it to. If someone else wants to make Christmas about Santa and reindeer and spending cash, that's their choice. But it's not like I'm forced into it. I can make other decisions. The Christian meaning... that's so broad, and you could look it up online. I'll just tell you the meaning of it for me. Christmas is the time to celebrate the birth of Christ, the birth of the Light of God into the world. Although Christ's birth probably occurred in the fall, not in December, the church put it by the Solstice. I think that's great. The Winter Solstice is the time the Pagans celebrate the rebirth of the sun, the rebirth of Light. It is a time to remember that even in the darkest night, the Light is coming to awaken us, to bring us to life. I can't think of a more fitting time to celebrate the coming of Jesus, who was the manifestation of the Light and Love of God without measure, onto Earth. So, in both my Solstice and Christmas ceremonies, I celebrate this Light with the faith that the peace, joy, and love of God will soon be birthed into the world even more. The renewal of hope.

Easter is a time to celebrate Christ's resurrection- His overcoming death. And in spring, that's a perfect time to see everything come to life. In the Anglican (and Catholic) traditions, there is a whole series of events leading to Easter. It is not an isolated holiday. People give up something for Lent, which reminds us of the value of sacrifice and self-discipline. We observe the Last Supper on Maundy Thursday and the sorrow of Christ's cruxifiction through services on Good Friday. On Sunday, we joyfully celebrate Christ overcoming death and sin through the resurrection.
7) I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?
Lent is, for me, a time to sacrifice something and practice self-discipline in some area of my life. It is common among Lutheran and Anglican/Episcopalian traditions. I do not know if other Protestants practice it. My guess is that it fell out of the other denominations over time. I find it useful- it's a good practice for breaking bad habits, for becoming more disciplined, for becoming more grateful of what we have, and so forth.
8) What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?
No clue. Never lived in an area that practiced this. I'm a West Coast gal.
9) Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?
As a Druid, there are plants that are sacred or important at various times of the year, and all food is sacred to me in that another being gave up its life for mine. But as a Christian, I don't find that food is sacred. Except the little communion wafers and wine, but I hardly recognize that as food.
10) Why is it so important that priests not marry?
My guess is that priests, monks, and nuns are thought better able to focus on their duties in the church without having the distractions of marriage and family. I mean, let's face it, spouse and kids takes up a lot of time, energy, and concern and there is less left over for a congregation or monastery. Spiritual practice is more difficult the more responsibilities you have. The flip side, in my opinion, is that when the clergy do not tackle the responsibilties their congregations have, they are less likely to have a real grasp on how difficult spiritual practice can be in the midst of mundane life. There may be less understanding, less practical advice on how to integrate the sacred and the ordinary.
11) Why can’t women become priests?
In my denomination, they can. There's a whole thread on here called "women priests" in the Belief and Spirituality section you may want to check out. I think there is no good reason why women cannot lead a congregation.
12) What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
For me, taking Eucharist is a symbolic reminder of Christ's growth within me, a reminder to empty myself of my own ego in order to be a vessel for Divine Love. I'm guessing Mass is like going to church. So it is a respite from ordinary life, a time to refocus on the spiritual, to be refreshed and redirected, a way to begin the week headed in the right direction.
13) What is the significance of Baptism?
I see it as a symbolic ritual of cleansing and new birth in Christ. I do not think it confers any magical properties, but is rather an outward symbol of an inward change.
14) Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children at birth?
Anglican families do this as a symbol of their commitment to raise the child in Christ's teachings. It is not thought to confer any spiritual properties (i.e., it doesn't mean the child is saved or something). It is a statement of commitment to the church community, and a time to ask for the church community's strength and support for that family.
15) What is a Rosary for?
I don't use one.
16) What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it?
In the Lutheran and Anglican churches, confirmation is when a person has completed a set of classes that ensure they know the fundamentals of the church and faith, and they commit to be a member of the church in this knowledge.
17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?
Christ's teachings on serving others, loving everyone (even enemies), forgiving everyone, working toward justice and equality, and living humbly, joyfully, and peacefully are pretty challenging, especially in the society we live in.
18) Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?
That's a long and complex history lesson. I think a lot of it was due to its adoption by Rome as a state religion, which tied it to governmental power and allowed it to expand along with the State. This same coupling of ruling elite and religion brought Christianity to much of the Americas and Africa. There are lots of good books on this.
19) Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world
At heart, I do not think they are so different. I meet Jews and Muslims that have all the same core beliefs and ethics I do; at the heart of it is love and connection to God. But alas, humans muck things up and our fears, insecurities, and egos get in the way of seeing unity.
20) Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?
I think what would be interesting is to look at the issue of the "official" answers from the denominations (i.e., those that are on church websites and literature) vs. the views you get from practitioners. I've personally seen a huge variety in practitioners' beliefs and practices in Catholicism and more broadly, Christianity, no matter how detailed their church's doctrine seemed to be.

Thank you all for the answers that I recieve.
You're welcome! Best, Path/Kim
 
student77...


1) How has Christianity and/or the Catholic denomination shaped your life?
positively, and negatively- negatively, priests telling me I'm a devil worshipper at 9 didn't boost my ego much, but thankfully, my jesus wasn't their jesus, so I didnt take much notice... positively... it taught me about charity, and that ppl worse off than me existed, and I could help them...

2) What is your understanding of God from the Christian point of view?
god is the big deal... he's not called jehovah, and is more like the holy spirit...

3) How is the Catholic denomination different from other Christian
denominations? I know that there are many similarities.

catholics are the true faith, the rest are just pretenders...

4) What are the important holidays and traditions of Christianity, specifically Catholicism? christmas, easter, lent, baptism, marriage, funerals, getting the priest drunk at christmas, for fun...

5) How do these holidays differ from other Christian denominations, if they differ? they dont... much...

6) What is the Christian meaning of Christmas and Easter, and how has commercialization and the secular world taken away from that?

I, like many others, believe jesus was born around september and that both xmas and easter are pagan festival which were altered by the church to ensure the new religion looked like the old one, and wouldn't upset ppl too much...

7) I live in Louisiana, and have noticed that Lent is very much observed. What is lent, and why does it exist? Why does it seem more important in the Catholic denomination than in other Christian denominations?

lent is a time for catholics to lose weight and clean out their closets, donating used tat to the poor... you can also have an excuse to moan, especially on maundy thursday, and you get to wear an itchy sack and cover yourself in ash on wednesday...

8) What is the significance of Fat Tuesday and Mardi Gras?
see above...

9) Are there certain foods that are sacred or important? And why?

fish... jesus like fish... erm, and wine, he liked that, too... and bread...

10) Why is it so important that priests not marry?

because they are supposedly channelling God, interceding on the behalf of the people with jesus, and for this they need to be pure, and chaste, and not masturbate before Mass...

11) Why can’t women become priests?
see above...

12) What is the purpose of Communion and Mass?
communion welcomes u into the church officially, mass is what you do afterwards...

13) What is the significance of Baptism?
nobody knows...

14) Why do Catholics and other Christian denominations baptize children
at birth?
because if we waited til they were 18 the numbers would be considerably less...

15) What is a Rosary for? neurotics...

16) What is confirmation? And, what is the importance of it? ur baptised, as a child, ur parents wish, then u make communion, at about 7, far too young to decide about God... at around 13/14 years old, u confirm it- as an adult, supposedly... and you take a new name, preferably from a dead saint...

17) What are the challenges, if any, to practicing the Christian religion?

genuflecting with arthritis: skill level: high

18) Why do you think that Christianity has become the majority religion in the world today?

after burning the witches and infecting the indians with cholera resistance was sparce..

19) Historically, Christianity, Judaism and the Islamic faith all start from the same point? What is your opinion on the reason why they began to split and have become so different in today’s world

they are still more or less the same...

20) Is there any other significant or important information that you would like me to know, or that I have neglected to ask?

no


Thank you all for the answers that I recieve.[/quote]
 
I am a college student writing a paper about Christianity, it is a comparative paper. I am looking for someone to answer some questions about Christianity for me from the Christian point of view. The information from the questions will be used to help me provide material to my paper and to give me a Christian perspective for my studies.

If there is someone on this forum that would like to help me out please let me know and I will post my questions.

Thank you

lol.... Yeah that is going to be a "mixed bag" of answers on that paper lol....

Oh and question 8, answer to have a blast :D
 
Back
Top