Religion 'linked to happy life'

wil

wil

UNeyeR1
Veteran Member
Messages
24,586
Reaction score
3,960
Points
108
Location
a figment of your imagination
A belief in God could lead to a more contented life, research suggests.

Religious people are better able to cope with shocks such as losing a job or divorce, claims the study presented to a Royal Economic Society conference. Data from thousands of Europeans revealed higher levels of "life satisfaction" in believers. more from the BBC...

Sort of related, from a Christian youth group leadership weekend, one of the girls responded to "If you can combine any two things what would they be?" she said "I'd combine rose colored glasses with everyone's eyes. So they could have a new perspective on life."
 
Lol... definitely a " no s**t Sherlock" study that one. I propose a name for this.... "Ostrich Syndrome".

Tao
 
The president of the National Secular Society appears to equate happiness simply with time bound experiences rather than a more consistent state of mind or outlook on life.

s.
 
Tao_Equus said:
Lol... definitely a " no s**t Sherlock" study that one. I propose a name for this.... "Ostrich Syndrome".
Click to expand...
What do you want to take the blue pill or the red pill?

If we are in bliss and wish to stay there, what vicarious thrill do you receive from waking us up?
 
wil said:
What do you want to take the blue pill or the red pill?

If we are in bliss and wish to stay there, what vicarious thrill do you receive from waking us up?
Click to expand...

Absolutely none what so ever...!! I am green with envy!! :D

Tao
 
Justin Thacker, head of Theology for the Evangelical Alliance, said that there should now be no doubt about the connection between religious belief and happiness. "There is more than one reason for this - part of it will be the sense of community and the relationships fostered, but that doesn't account for all of it.
"A large part of it is due to the meaning, purpose and value which believing in God gives you, whereas not believing in God can leave you without those things.
Click to expand...

Did you ever get the feeling you were being talked down to? :rolleyes:

I mean really, this sounds like he's talking to a bunch of errant children. "See what can happen if you don't believe, the blue meanies will get you!"
 
"The belief that religion damages people is still in the minds of many."
Click to expand...

lol, no wonder David believes that they have the ostrich syndrome.
 
Paladin said:
Did you ever get the feeling you were being talked down to? :rolleyes:

I mean really, this sounds like he's talking to a bunch of errant children. "See what can happen if you don't believe, the blue meanies will get you!"
Click to expand...
Yet the errant children get that feeling they are being talked down to. :rolleyes:

When God speaks, should I shake my fist and exclaim how wrong he is to talk down to me?

That could have been many other subjects: marriage, giving to others, being honest, confessing, trusting others, eating healthy, getting exercise, doing the homework, being timely to work, loving those who hate you, ... someone may tend to not only disagree, but light themselves a fire over their internal feeling they are being talked down to.
 
cyberpi said:
Yet the errant children get that feeling they are being talked down to. :rolleyes:

When God speaks, should I shake my fist and exclaim how wrong he is to talk down to me?

That could have been many other subjects: marriage, giving to others, being honest, confessing, trusting others, eating healthy, getting exercise, doing the homework, being timely to work, loving those who hate you, ... someone may tend to not only disagree, but light themselves a fire over their internal feeling they are being talked down to.
Click to expand...

Wow a reply that was directly relevant to what I said, and wasn't a non-sequitur how very charming! I went back over the article and didn't see God being quoted, I did see what a man said however and it is that I had a problem with. Not everyone in the religious business is channeling God are they because few of them seem to agree with one another.

Yes I do believe the tone in that statement was patronizing. Somehow I cannot believe that God would need to be patronizing. Of course religion does tend to anthropomorphise God when it suits them.
 
Paladin said:
Wow a reply that was directly relevant to what I said, and wasn't a non-sequitur how very charming!
Click to expand...
Your call as always.

Paladin said:
I went back over the article and didn't see God being quoted, I did see what a man said however and it is that I had a problem with.
Click to expand...
If Jesus were standing before you, would you see God being quoted?

If a homeless person on the street, a fried drug user, or my own children speak to me as if to teach me a lesson, should I shake my fist and exclaim how wrong it is to talk down to me?

I will answer the question: NO... and that goes for everyone between them and God. If I did, then I would be an errant child feeling talked down to, with my own pride blinding me. If I did, I would be of little help to them or to myself.

Paladin said:
Not everyone in the religious business is channeling God are they because few of them seem to agree with one another.
Click to expand...
Whether sequitur or non-sequitur, I see your alleged logic being applied on top of your assumptions. Is it God's will that everyone agree with one another? Is it God's will that everyone speak the same language? Does God necessarily need men to channel a message?

Paladin said:
Yes I do believe the tone in that statement was patronizing. Somehow I cannot believe that God would need to be patronizing.
Click to expand...
Your call... how does the following sound: "You serpents, you generation of vipers... how will you escape the judgment of hell?"

Paladin said:
Of course religion does tend to anthropomorphise God when it suits them.
Click to expand...
And you or I don't? The institutions outside of whatever you are calling religion does not?

With my closest relationships as an example, while I know they exist and I know some of the will of the other person... I do not fully know their will. Neither do I fully know how my will appears to them. It is the same with God. Is that anthropomorphising God, as you say, or simply due to my own anthropomorphised state that I have to work with.
 
Paladin said:
Did you ever get the feeling you were being talked down to? :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Yes, I can see that — However the article is dealing with effects rather than causes, and so your response is understandable but a tad unfair. It's just stating the 'facts' as the data presents — that people with an active religious dimension to their lives seem to have a more robust psychological constitution. I don't think it's talking down to anyone, it's just making an unsupported claim according to the data.

What it does not do is place the findings in any useful context. As a secularist Terry Sanderson replied
that studies purporting to show a link between happiness and religion were "all meaningless"
Click to expand...
— which is the case if there is no accompanying vision of the human being as a person that explains the data.

He goes on:
"Non-believers can't just turn on a faith in order to be happy. If you find religious claims incredible, then you won't believe them, whatever the supposed rewards in terms of personal fulfilment.
Click to expand...
And I couldn't agree more, but that is a subjective response to objective data. That one finds such claims incredible does not mean they are, as there are others who find them credible and convincing, so we're left with individual coping mechanisms and capacities.

Thomas
 
Thomas,
I couldn't agree more that people who have great faith are more likely to weather the "slings and arrows..." but I don't think I'm being unfair in response to the statement that these things are unavailable to those who don't subscribe to a religion that holds a God concept.

An adherent of Zen for example might be quite content and be able to see and feel deeply the wonder and beauty of life but never reduce the majesty of the all in all to what some call God. Okay, maybe I'm expecting more from an article that is directed to everyday people whose world is much simpler, whose needs are more circumspect.
 
Tao_Equus said:
This is the kind of political thinking we need more of.
Tao
Click to expand...

Are you sure Tao, cos it’s based on “Buddhist spiritual values” (as per the Wiki page) ;)

Until recently there was relatively little crime in Bhutan and then Western TV channels were allowed into the country. Guess what’s happening now (it’s not difficult)…


As an aside, we have a sign hanging up at home that says “Gross Domestic Happiness” :D

s.
 
China Cat Sunflower said:
Is this the "opiate" effect?

Chris
Click to expand...
Self induced happiness? Would the opiate lover wash the feet of his neighbor? I have mentioned terms like 'sacrifice' or 'confession' to a few opiate addicts and received either lies or duplicitous reasonings why they were exempt. One insisted that God wanted everyone to be happy and that my words were not making him happy... of course, he was also the one who missed a sign and drove the wrong way down the freeway.

John 13:17 If you know these things, happy are you if you do them.

So then by the reasoning presented so far that would mean that Jesus was patronizing. What a patronizer. How dare he suggest that I am happy if I wash the feet of my neighbor... and know why. He forgot to mention Zen Buddhism. He did not mention the introspective who might just prefer to wash their own feet, and clear their own mind.

When an opiate is removed, it is easy to spot an addiction.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top