lunamoth
Episcopalian
Hi All,
I've been thinking about the spectrum of pacifism lately, not only in regard to how our various candidates view acts of national defense and war, but at a more personal level of where, exactly, I am as a pacifist.
My daughter (8 years old) would like to take karate, and this has brought me to think more deeply about what I want to teach her with repsect to non-violence. The karate school we have looked at does have as part of its creed that she will only "fight to protect herself and the lives of others." I think about that line very carefully.
I consider myself a pacifist, but not a strict pacifist because I know that I would fight physically against immediate threats to myself and my family, as in someone physically threatening immediate injury or death. I don't believe there is such a thing as just war, but I do think there are times when fighting against another nation or group is the least of evils to choose from.
I do believe in passive resistance, such as Ghandi's march to the sea and peaceful protest. So, I don't believe in total non-resistance to evil (completely detaching and not doing anything in the face of injustice and suffering).
But, I don't believe in pre-emptive wars, or war as anything but an aboslute last resort. I don't believe in retaliation, either personal or communal, national (Joe Biden's going out to bloody the bully's nose after the fact). War is just so tricky because the motives are so mixed...individual good can be done in the face of war, but overall it's just a mess.
Anyway, I wonder if I'll be giving my daughter a mixed message if I encourage her in karate, but tell her that violence is absolutely wrong.
Thoughts?
I've been thinking about the spectrum of pacifism lately, not only in regard to how our various candidates view acts of national defense and war, but at a more personal level of where, exactly, I am as a pacifist.
My daughter (8 years old) would like to take karate, and this has brought me to think more deeply about what I want to teach her with repsect to non-violence. The karate school we have looked at does have as part of its creed that she will only "fight to protect herself and the lives of others." I think about that line very carefully.
I consider myself a pacifist, but not a strict pacifist because I know that I would fight physically against immediate threats to myself and my family, as in someone physically threatening immediate injury or death. I don't believe there is such a thing as just war, but I do think there are times when fighting against another nation or group is the least of evils to choose from.
I do believe in passive resistance, such as Ghandi's march to the sea and peaceful protest. So, I don't believe in total non-resistance to evil (completely detaching and not doing anything in the face of injustice and suffering).
But, I don't believe in pre-emptive wars, or war as anything but an aboslute last resort. I don't believe in retaliation, either personal or communal, national (Joe Biden's going out to bloody the bully's nose after the fact). War is just so tricky because the motives are so mixed...individual good can be done in the face of war, but overall it's just a mess.
Anyway, I wonder if I'll be giving my daughter a mixed message if I encourage her in karate, but tell her that violence is absolutely wrong.
Thoughts?